Reply
SwimHipster
SlitneyBoobston
Posts: 1,645
Registered: ‎02-12-2012

When did Itchy and Scratchy jump the shark?

I don't even need to watch that whole supercut of all the I&S episodes to guess it was around the time when the cat and mouse duo were doing more topical material, i.e. the steroid hearings or "The King's Speech".

 

Now, I'm not against them doing parody.  They got great mileage out of the guest directors Tarantino and Stone, but there's a time and a place for that kind of gratuitious satire.

 

Really, it wasn't Poochie that caused it.  It wasn't the wildly successful movie, either (or the movie seen in "The Simpsons Movie").  Heck, the theme park was a landmark of fun and frolic.

 

Nay, I think it's when they started talking.  It was fine at first, but once the writers started giving June Bellamy more dialogue, it became less about the massacre of a cat and more about the mastication of a word-bat.

 

But still, that musical had some great songs in it.

Is there no place for the man with the 105 IQ?
Moonlight Butterfly
Chappi_The_Rabbit
Posts: 35,167
Registered: ‎07-12-2007

Re: When did Itchy and Scratchy jump the shark?

Reply to SlitneyBoobston - Message ID#: 64175659

They jumped the shark when they tried to go for the "all ages" approach with the loving and sharing Itchy and Scratchy after that lawsuit with the soccermoms. The show's creator really budged and caved in, and that's not the sign of a competant staff. Hell, not even Bonestorm had to go through that much censorship and that threatened people to buy it or they would "go to hell".

"If you like to gamble, I'll tell you I'm your man. You win some, you lose some, it's all the same to me."
ユニバァァァス! ユニバァァァァァァァァァァァァァァァス!
SwimFan
ShlickShlickShlick
Posts: 775
Registered: ‎02-29-2012
0

Re: When did Itchy and Scratchy jump the shark?

Reply to Chappi_The_Rabbit - Message ID#: 64175903

I'll grant you that the infamous lemonade episode was bad, but I would say that it jumped back and forth for a while, especially with the ill-fated Poochie episode, but it's definitely been missing more than hitting repeatedly until entertaining blood shoots forth.
I woke up with a clown's hand down my pants. That's how my day went.
Swimmortal
westpark
Posts: 59,269
Registered: ‎10-26-2005

Re: When did Itchy and Scratchy jump the shark?

Reply to SlitneyBoobston - Message ID#: 64175659

Probably a decade or so ago when the Simpsons jumped it.

WESTPARK THE KING OF ASMB

"westpark ran a train on this thread" - Stilgar

"Every woman needs a good slap now & again." - Sir Sean Connery
SwimFan
PsychoLezUSA
Posts: 515
Registered: ‎02-29-2012
0

Re: When did Itchy and Scratchy jump the shark?

Reply to westpark - Message ID#: 64182385

Sure, yeah, if you want to get meta about it.
He thinks he's the Pope of Chilitown!
Swimmortal
westpark
Posts: 59,269
Registered: ‎10-26-2005
0

Re: When did Itchy and Scratchy jump the shark?

Reply to PsychoLezUSA - Message ID#: 64182471


PsychoLezUSA wrote:
Sure, yeah, if you want to get meta about it.

I never really got into the Simpsons or Itchy/Scratchy. I always liked Futurama better. 

 

The first few Simpsons were awesome. But that came out like when I was 6 or 7 or something like that. Back then it was all edgy. Now its hilariously boring.

WESTPARK THE KING OF ASMB

"westpark ran a train on this thread" - Stilgar

"Every woman needs a good slap now & again." - Sir Sean Connery
SwimFan
PsychoLezUSA
Posts: 515
Registered: ‎02-29-2012
0

Re: When did Itchy and Scratchy jump the shark?

Reply to westpark - Message ID#: 64182573

You seem like someone who would have come to Futurama first, despite being older than me.
He thinks he's the Pope of Chilitown!