Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Do you mean 
Reply
Mysterious Ooze
DubV
Posts: 3,936
Registered: ‎02-24-2010
0

Bleach- Soul Eater

So who riped off who?

 

I mean i know alot of anime's rip eatch other off but this is ridiculous

 

here's just some of the simularitys:

 

Talking cat who turns in to a sexy woman

 

they have sword like Zanpaktu's

 

They have Hollow Like creatures (forgot what soul eater calls them)

 

Soul Reaper Academy.

 

I mean all that and i only watch 7 episodes geez.

WATCH TOONAMI SO THEY COULD MAKES MONEYS TO BUY NEW ANIMES

DoubleV = DubV

Anime is a side of me my friends will never understand

But at least i have you guys.....

"As long as I'm breathing, this place and it's rules can #### MY ####!" - Ganta

Zombie Slayer
Posts: 379
Registered: ‎06-05-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55195527

i think bleach was around 1st but not for sure

Zombie Slayer
finity
Posts: 147
Registered: ‎07-07-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55195527

Might check it out.

 

 

Soul Eater was released sometime between June and November 2003.

The line and the sand is drawn and I have no fear.

Thanks for tearing the world apart.


I'm not just some boy you can sway.

Zombie Slayer
Posts: 379
Registered: ‎06-05-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to finity - Message ID#: 55196899

bleach came out in 2001 so it was 1st

Zombie Slayer
finity
Posts: 147
Registered: ‎07-07-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to SalamoreBlood - Message ID#: 55197097

Mhm, so most likely, if they did rip some things from another anime, Soul Eater ripped them from Bleach. Who knows though, I'm gonna check it out and get back to you all later.

The line and the sand is drawn and I have no fear.

Thanks for tearing the world apart.


I'm not just some boy you can sway.

Hell's Minions
fire-flash
Posts: 45,694
Registered: ‎08-31-2008
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

[ Edited ]

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55195527

Actually to be honest Soul Eater is more of a mix of Bleach, Naruto and Shaman King

 

Edit: and also Soul Eater has some originality as far as I know

Mysterious Ooze
edichgolight
Posts: 3,922
Registered: ‎04-13-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55195527

bleach came first. but its not really a rip off. its only a rip

off if the stories are similar, which they aren't. different mangas

take multiple things from each other.

"TINY MINISKIRTS"
-Roy Mustang at his greatest

"I hate violence"
-Shizuo Heiwajima (Durarara)
Pumpkin Guts
vaccine
Posts: 1,135
Registered: ‎01-03-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55195527

There's plenty of similarities that's for sure, and bleach came first.

Soul Eater on it's own however is a very good anime /manga asides from all that.
The Bleach forums need you!
A character guide is in the process of being made, for more info on how you could help fill out your favorite character, please visit this thread. Thanks!
Zombie Slayer
finity
Posts: 147
Registered: ‎07-07-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to vaccine - Message ID#: 55202233

Just watched the first episode, it's caught my attention so far. But, the grim reaper is a little to cartoony.

The line and the sand is drawn and I have no fear.

Thanks for tearing the world apart.


I'm not just some boy you can sway.

Mysterious Ooze
DubV
Posts: 3,936
Registered: ‎02-24-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

[ Edited ]

Reply to finity - Message ID#: 55204505

you kinda get past the cartoonie part after a few episodes,

 

and im not saying that this is a bad anime it's just funny  how mutch they took from bleach.

WATCH TOONAMI SO THEY COULD MAKES MONEYS TO BUY NEW ANIMES

DoubleV = DubV

Anime is a side of me my friends will never understand

But at least i have you guys.....

"As long as I'm breathing, this place and it's rules can #### MY ####!" - Ganta

Pumpkin Guts
vaccine
Posts: 1,135
Registered: ‎01-03-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55204601

I actually like the Grim Reaper's voice in the sub. :smileyvery-happy:
The Bleach forums need you!
A character guide is in the process of being made, for more info on how you could help fill out your favorite character, please visit this thread. Thanks!
Pumpkin King
elfie
Posts: 35,401
Registered: ‎04-13-2004
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

[ Edited ]

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55195527

No one ripped off anybody. 

 

The themes and subject matters used in both are common in anime.

 

By your logic, you'd also wonder how Kekkaishi and Yu Yu Hakusho fit into the equation.

 

And I don't know what people say about cartooniness being bad.  In fact, it's one of the reason I got into Soul Eater in the first place.  How come people say the same thing about FullMetal Alchemist?

Mysterious Ooze
DubV
Posts: 3,936
Registered: ‎02-24-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to elfie - Message ID#: 55224693

Calm down elfie i was just making discussion.

 

I know my self that alot of Anime's go off idea's from other Anime's.

 

So lets just chill, what you say friends?:smileyhappy:

WATCH TOONAMI SO THEY COULD MAKES MONEYS TO BUY NEW ANIMES

DoubleV = DubV

Anime is a side of me my friends will never understand

But at least i have you guys.....

"As long as I'm breathing, this place and it's rules can #### MY ####!" - Ganta

Pumpkin Guts
Hakumen
Posts: 1,309
Registered: ‎06-14-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to vaccine - Message ID#: 55207519

I like more of the **alf** vas in general. The dub doesnt give as much emotion&feelings as the original does.....

"I am the cold steel. I am the Just Sword. With blade in hand shall I reap the sins of this world, and cleanse it in the fires of destruction. I am Hakumen, the end has come!"
Pumpkin King
elfie
Posts: 35,401
Registered: ‎04-13-2004
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to DubV - Message ID#: 55226261

 


DubV wrote:

Calm down elfie i was just making discussion.

 

I know my self that alot of Anime's go off idea's from other Anime's.

 

So lets just chill, what you say friends?:smileyhappy:


 

No offense taken.  My criticism is often mistaken for yelling.  lol

Pumpkin Guts
Hakumen
Posts: 1,309
Registered: ‎06-14-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to elfie - Message ID#: 55229645

 


elfie wrote:

 


DubV wrote:

Calm down elfie i was just making discussion.

 

I know my self that alot of Anime's go off idea's from other Anime's.

 

So lets just chill, what you say friends?:smileyhappy:


 

No offense taken.  My criticism is often mistaken for yelling.  lol


Yelling helps people to understand your argument better :robotvery-happy:

 

"I am the cold steel. I am the Just Sword. With blade in hand shall I reap the sins of this world, and cleanse it in the fires of destruction. I am Hakumen, the end has come!"
Pumpkin Guts
vaccine
Posts: 1,135
Registered: ‎01-03-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

[ Edited ]

Reply to Hakumen - Message ID#: 55229763

 

 




Hakumen wrote

elfie wrote:


DubV wrote:

Calm down elfie i was just making discussion.


I know my self that alot of Anime's go off idea's from other Anime's.


So lets just chill, what you say friends?:smileyhappy:



No offense taken.  My criticism is often mistaken for yelling.  lol



Yelling helps people to understand your argument better :robotvery-happy:




 

I don't know what we're yelling about!

 

 

The Bleach forums need you!
A character guide is in the process of being made, for more info on how you could help fill out your favorite character, please visit this thread. Thanks!
Pumpkin Guts
Hakumen
Posts: 1,309
Registered: ‎06-14-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to vaccine - Message ID#: 55230851

Rofl you've been posting clip of Ron Burgundy alot lately

But i'm not complaining :robotvery-happy:

"I am the cold steel. I am the Just Sword. With blade in hand shall I reap the sins of this world, and cleanse it in the fires of destruction. I am Hakumen, the end has come!"
Pumpkin Guts
vaccine
Posts: 1,135
Registered: ‎01-03-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to Hakumen - Message ID#: 55230935

and you are a smelly pirate hooker
The Bleach forums need you!
A character guide is in the process of being made, for more info on how you could help fill out your favorite character, please visit this thread. Thanks!
Zombie Slayer
finity
Posts: 147
Registered: ‎07-07-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to vaccine - Message ID#: 55231321

Wizard.

The line and the sand is drawn and I have no fear.

Thanks for tearing the world apart.


I'm not just some boy you can sway.

Bone-ified Ghoul
CorbeauKarasu
Posts: 10,068
Registered: ‎03-14-2008
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to SalamoreBlood - Message ID#: 55195827

you're not sure? Bleach was around way before Soul Eater. however, Soul Eater doesn't rip off Bleach 'cause Bleach is terrible and Soul Eater is the antithesis of that.

Je Suis Faucon
Azure Knight
Zombie Slayer
Posts: 379
Registered: ‎06-05-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to CorbeauKarasu - Message ID#: 55232701

wow we got one of these guys now ehhh how i grow tired of useless people like u just talking c rap

Bone-ified Ghoul
CorbeauKarasu
Posts: 10,068
Registered: ‎03-14-2008
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to SalamoreBlood - Message ID#: 55233509

oh wow. you've surely gained notoriety and popularity by pretending to be a badass.

Bleach was fun in the beginning, but Kubo's storytelling completely fell apart near the end of the soul society arc and continued to dissolve as time went on. it's become nigh unintelligible now - an endless exercise in plot hole recycling and deus ex machina power ups.

Soul Eater's anime version had problems near the end, but all around, it's plot and characters are much better than those of Bleach and the ongoing manga continues to get better and better. I find it hard to believe that anyone could think Soul Eater came before Bleach, but I guess we also have people on these boards who think Dragon Ball Z is from ten years ago, so I shouldn't be surprised at your ignorance.
Je Suis Faucon
Azure Knight
Zombie Slayer
Posts: 379
Registered: ‎06-05-2010
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to CorbeauKarasu - Message ID#: 55233845

my my my  dont we have a fun little troll here really man u bore me with ur meaningless trolling

  

1st off i have only watched soul eater not read it so when i said i wasnt sure which came 1st  i was talking about the manga

 

furthermore if u dont like the show then dont come on these borads trolls like u always have some thing to say that they think is smart but all it is is a display of ignorance on ur  part

 

so bye now have a good ! come back when u have some thing intelligent  to say or at lest not as boring

Bone-ified Ghoul
CorbeauKarasu
Posts: 10,068
Registered: ‎03-14-2008
0

Re: Bleach- Soul Eater

Reply to SalamoreBlood - Message ID#: 55235653

Soul Eater's manga is also relatively new, especially in comparison to Bleach. Your argument, once again, is invalid.
Je Suis Faucon
Azure Knight