Reply
SwimGuru
ben0119
Posts: 18,903
Registered: ‎07-16-2003
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64067333

Quoting what I said in the other threads since the OP needed to feel important and have them locked so he could start his own thread for no reason:


Yes, not only is Kenpachi's new voice actor awful, but they wrote some goofy-ass lines for him tonight.  "Get down... I must rampage."  Did I really hear that right?  It also doesn't help that Kenpachi was drawn pretty bad too.  He barely looked like himself.

 

This new Kenpachi voice actor is horrible.  He sounds like a big dumb brutish oaf and a tenth as manly.  Kenpachi was supposed to sound savage, threatening, but also have some cunning and intelligence behind his voice.  This new guy has none of that.  You can tell the new actor is trying too hard to sound like that.  With the original actor, you could tell it very much came naturally.  

 

From what I can tell, this might be Patrick Seitz pulling double duty.  It seems that, as talented as he is, he just doesn't make a good Kenpachi.  Still, if it is Seitz, and since we're in filler which I understand is Kenpachi-heavy, maybe he'll improve enough to not suck by the time canon returns.  We can only hope.

 

What happened to the original Urahara and Kenpachi voice actors?  Why would you replace them with people who can't even fill their shoes?!

 


BethSycamore wrote:

 I don't find anything wrong with Zaraki's voice,his voice sounds alright to me.


I don't see how you couldn't be bothered by it, but good for you, I suppose.  If I wasn't bothered by it, I could have actually fully enjoyed tonight's episode.


forethought wrote:

Yes, what ben0119 says is true. The new voice is oaflish, with no hint of cunning or intelligence. The voice lines are also just oafish, "i must rampage"??

 

Kempachi isn't a dumb brute, he has tactics and intelligence. I also think that ben0119 is also correct, it seems that Patrick Seitz is the "new" kempachi voice actor. He is good at ichigo father, but he isn't able to do kempachi correctly. 


Thanks, I noticed that no one else pointed that out.  I was planning on saying it anyway, but it's all the better I did since no one else said that.  

 

I really can't get over some of the lines.  They're just ridiculously goofy.  I can't remember most of them, at the moment, though, outside of the one I already mentioned. 

 

And yeah, Seitz did a good job in every other role, such as Masamori on Kekkaishi, Simon on DRRR, Isshin on Bleach, etc... but for some reason, even he can't be badass enough to be Kenpachi.  I hope he improves by the time canon returns, but I don't know... this just... isn't working at all, and it didn't get any better as the episode went along tonight, either.


In any case, the Sado voice actor change was only temporary, and during the dreaded Unspeakable Arc which I did not watch much of, so I never noticed it.  But, he went back to his old voice quickly enough.  I thought this issue had been decided and buried, already...

I FINALLY GOT A NEW PC! FREEDOM! }{ My Deviant Art Page }{ Me and my Seth Green autographed Titan Maximum S1 DVD! }{ Sate your hunger for FMA! }{ Someone please give us a complete post tracker! }{ AIM: BenO0119 }{ RAVE MASTER CONTINUES! THE MANGA DISCUSSION }{ Rukia Kuchiki Fan Club! (spoiler-free!) }{ "Traps, is that what you call my simple diversions?" - Naraku }{ "Are you actually crying, Vash the Stampede? That is wonderful, truly wonderful." - Legato
SwimGuru
ben0119
Posts: 18,903
Registered: ‎07-16-2003
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to helpme - Message ID#: 64082237


helpme wrote:
its best for the boards
Besides having all these complaint threads isn't really helping either

This thread is a combination of all the next VA threads should they come up

Also the Mods have nothing to do with this I made this thread to end all the other threads
think of it as a Discussion thread on VA

No, it's not.  It's best for you, so you can wave your e-peen around and feel more important and rack up the replies, attention, and other various stats.

 

We had one complaint thread.  It was a good one, made by udsha, an intelligent, literate ASMBer that I respect.  The thread was about the crappy new Kenpachi VA and served its purpose well.  It's not our fault that blind noobs made their own threads after that, and that certainly doesn't justify you asking the mods to lock his and other's threads because you deemed yours "the thread to end all threads" and so much better than theirs.  

 

Udsha will not be pleased that you had his thread locked.  I thought only makers of their own threads could decide such things, yet you get the mods to mess with someone else's thread... wtf.

 

And yes, the mods did have something to do with it, because you went behind our backs and had them lock the threads.  It's seriously unnecessary and just stirs up more shit, just so you can feel like you're important and "solving a problem" and "helping".  Pfft.  We had a good thread going, then you make another one... adding to the problem, then retroactively say OH THIS IS THE RIGHT THREAD TO POST IN GUYS GO POST IN MY THREAD.  Ugh.. -_- 

 

Oh, and this thread also has the extremely annoying bitching that subbies do about any English voice actor because you didn't specify the complaints be about English voice actors changing to another English voice actor.  Yeah, I really wanted more of that.  That, which was completely gone from the boards until you gave them this thread to complain in and reminded them about all the English voices they hate, even though most of them can't understand Japanese and can't properly judge the original performances anyway.  Logic, it exists not here.  

 

And no, I don't think it will cut down or prevent them from complaining about a new English VA that doesn't fit their fancy in the episode threads, and it won't stop noobs from making countless complaint threads in the future, either.  Your thread isn't going to magically act as a barrier to keep people from doing stupid crap.

I FINALLY GOT A NEW PC! FREEDOM! }{ My Deviant Art Page }{ Me and my Seth Green autographed Titan Maximum S1 DVD! }{ Sate your hunger for FMA! }{ Someone please give us a complete post tracker! }{ AIM: BenO0119 }{ RAVE MASTER CONTINUES! THE MANGA DISCUSSION }{ Rukia Kuchiki Fan Club! (spoiler-free!) }{ "Traps, is that what you call my simple diversions?" - Naraku }{ "Are you actually crying, Vash the Stampede? That is wonderful, truly wonderful." - Legato
Otaku Info Broker
helpme
Posts: 40,179
Registered: ‎07-27-2004
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to ben0119 - Message ID#: 64082349

dude you need to chill
why bash me if you have a complaint take it up with Muse
MyAnimeList
Anime Manga More website
Either way Don't have fun or I will hunt it down and kill it ~SwimModPerseus
Take a chill pill. Log off. You're being a jackass, and it's annoying ~SwimOdin
Come back from a weekend and you guys are trying to castrate each other Jeeze ~SwimMod_Bast
Knight SwimDeath main account 














SwimGuru
ben0119
Posts: 18,903
Registered: ‎07-16-2003
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to helpme - Message ID#: 64082379

I'm not bashing you, I'm bashing the incompetence and illogicalness of this decision and course of action, and I seriously doubt me "taking it up with Muse" will do any good, since she's the one you originally had do your dirty work.

I FINALLY GOT A NEW PC! FREEDOM! }{ My Deviant Art Page }{ Me and my Seth Green autographed Titan Maximum S1 DVD! }{ Sate your hunger for FMA! }{ Someone please give us a complete post tracker! }{ AIM: BenO0119 }{ RAVE MASTER CONTINUES! THE MANGA DISCUSSION }{ Rukia Kuchiki Fan Club! (spoiler-free!) }{ "Traps, is that what you call my simple diversions?" - Naraku }{ "Are you actually crying, Vash the Stampede? That is wonderful, truly wonderful." - Legato
Otaku Info Broker
helpme
Posts: 40,179
Registered: ‎07-27-2004
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to ben0119 - Message ID#: 64082595

actually I tired Raijin
but he seems to ignore me

so I usually go to fastest action PM's
though Bast Retired and I lost interest in posting for some reason

..........hmm I'll talk to muse maybe she can undo all this
MyAnimeList
Anime Manga More website
Either way Don't have fun or I will hunt it down and kill it ~SwimModPerseus
Take a chill pill. Log off. You're being a jackass, and it's annoying ~SwimOdin
Come back from a weekend and you guys are trying to castrate each other Jeeze ~SwimMod_Bast
Knight SwimDeath main account 














SwimGuru
ben0119
Posts: 18,903
Registered: ‎07-16-2003
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to helpme - Message ID#: 64082623

Do what you think is best.

 

Personally, I would have locked all the other threads and just directed people to udsha's thread, since his was first.  I'm also not the only person that pointed out the ridiculousness, ludicrousness, and sheer audacity of you telling us to go post in a new thread you just made, when udsha's thread was made first and we were already at home there.

 

It's also worth noting that there's also already an "Offical Complain about the Dub" thread, or something similarly titled, so that's where the subbies should be complaining about dub actors being lesser humans than their precious "Seiyuu", not here. 

I FINALLY GOT A NEW PC! FREEDOM! }{ My Deviant Art Page }{ Me and my Seth Green autographed Titan Maximum S1 DVD! }{ Sate your hunger for FMA! }{ Someone please give us a complete post tracker! }{ AIM: BenO0119 }{ RAVE MASTER CONTINUES! THE MANGA DISCUSSION }{ Rukia Kuchiki Fan Club! (spoiler-free!) }{ "Traps, is that what you call my simple diversions?" - Naraku }{ "Are you actually crying, Vash the Stampede? That is wonderful, truly wonderful." - Legato
Otaku Info Broker
helpme
Posts: 40,179
Registered: ‎07-27-2004
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to ben0119 - Message ID#: 64082689

ok then
that should work

now then I hope I have enough battery to make the pm out right
muti tasking seems to wear you out a lot faster then it should have

ok then I'll get to it
MyAnimeList
Anime Manga More website
Either way Don't have fun or I will hunt it down and kill it ~SwimModPerseus
Take a chill pill. Log off. You're being a jackass, and it's annoying ~SwimOdin
Come back from a weekend and you guys are trying to castrate each other Jeeze ~SwimMod_Bast
Knight SwimDeath main account 














Order of the Owl
MegaNaraku
Posts: 27,882
Registered: ‎11-26-2009
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to helpme - Message ID#: 64082745

I think it would be best if the arguing stopped and we could get back on topic O.O
:heart: Bleach :heart: :heart: Me IRL :heart: :heart: Sword Art Online :heart:

I'm an Owl! PSN: DemonLord99

~Proud business man of the Galactic Bird Flower Gang~

~And a proud member of Team 10,000~

SwimHipster
robertje
Posts: 1,791
Registered: ‎11-23-2009

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to helpme - Message ID#: 64082745

wtf does it matter where ppl post? it really doesnt make sense if one is closed and another is opened. if one thread closes just go and post in another one. whats it take to copy and paste? 2 minutes max??? this is dumb, back on topic..... I personally dont care what kenpachi sounds like he never really talked a whole lot anyways and was more of a get to the fighting character anyways, my complaint is really with urahara i just cant get over his voice lol just does not suit him lol

"Si vis paccem parra bellum" -If you want peace prepare for war!
"Watching in the darkness, Forever in darkness, a guardian devil"
"You can't end a good party without someone on the floor" -Yusuke Urameshi
Order of the Owl
MegaNaraku
Posts: 27,882
Registered: ‎11-26-2009
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to robertje - Message ID#: 64088927

I didn't think Urahara's voice is that bad
:heart: Bleach :heart: :heart: Me IRL :heart: :heart: Sword Art Online :heart:

I'm an Owl! PSN: DemonLord99

~Proud business man of the Galactic Bird Flower Gang~

~And a proud member of Team 10,000~

SwimHipster
robertje
Posts: 1,791
Registered: ‎11-23-2009
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to MegaNaraku - Message ID#: 64091793

doesnt it sound off, idk why that bugs me more than kenpachi, personally i dont mind his voice. Also Do you think they will go back to the originals after this arc or perm. 

"Si vis paccem parra bellum" -If you want peace prepare for war!
"Watching in the darkness, Forever in darkness, a guardian devil"
"You can't end a good party without someone on the floor" -Yusuke Urameshi
Order of the Owl
MegaNaraku
Posts: 27,882
Registered: ‎11-26-2009
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to robertje - Message ID#: 64115649

It doesn't really sound off to me. I dunno. I hope we have the originals back after this arc or sooner
:heart: Bleach :heart: :heart: Me IRL :heart: :heart: Sword Art Online :heart:

I'm an Owl! PSN: DemonLord99

~Proud business man of the Galactic Bird Flower Gang~

~And a proud member of Team 10,000~

SwimLucky
forethought
Posts: 777
Registered: ‎07-27-2008
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to MegaNaraku - Message ID#: 64118629

This thread title is an abomination. It implies hate, there is no hate, just doing such a drastic change of kenpachi voice changes his character completely. Such a change of a main character without any attempt to get a voice that fits the prior version of kenpachi voice that all the fans were used to is unforgivable.

 

To move our legitimate comments to a "one thread fits all hate thread edition" is wrong.

 

Our comments were about the kenpachi change, not hate, not about "voice actor changes".

 

Urahara, kiske, and chad did sound similar, and were in character with the originals. Kenpachi is not similiar at all. COMPLETELY different.

I watch adult swim because of Bleach. Everyone in my school watches Bleach.
SwimLucky
forethought
Posts: 777
Registered: ‎07-27-2008
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64121983

Vis media seems to be aware of the upset this is causing.. and are attempting to redirect the blame to ..

 

Studiopolis, Inc. is an American production company that specializes in voiceover recording and dubbing for animation, Japanese anime, and video games.

They were formerly known as Studio E Productions up until 2005. The studio produced the English version of the German animated film, Felidae which was only released on the film's DVD, only around Germany, Switzerland & Austria.

 

http://www.crystalacids.com/database/company/114/studiopolis-inc/

s

Studiopolis, Inc.

Email: ####

Website: www.StudiopolisInc.com

Mailing Address:
Studiopolis, Inc.
11700 Ventura Blvd.
Studio City, CA 91604

 

This is the studio responisble for chosing to pick Patrick Seitz ---- who they already have as a voice actor for ishin kurosaki--- as the "best" to replace kenpachi. I have to wonder if they even cared enough to find someone that could ACTUALLY do the kenpachi voice, tone, and mannerisms.

 

A larger website that is devoted to convincing them to change their poor poor choice is ideal.

 

But instead of posting in this dead end, thread that was designed to herd all of us into a catch all thread to be forgotten, we should be putting as much pressure on adult swim, and viz media to get this insult to fans fixed.

I watch adult swim because of Bleach. Everyone in my school watches Bleach.
SwimNerd
StalkerOfMods
Posts: 344
Registered: ‎02-29-2012
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64121983

If you have a problem Take it up with Muse
I'm not really thrilled that users are complaining about this thread I made

but in all serious it wasn't all that bad if anything I'm sure Muse can merge the other 2 with this one
http://boards.adultswim.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/82880
8


SwimLucky
forethought
Posts: 777
Registered: ‎07-27-2008
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to StalkerOfMods - Message ID#: 64122063


StalkerOfMods wrote:
If you have a problem Take it up with Muse
I'm not really thrilled that users are complaining about this thread I made

but in all serious it wasn't all that bad if anything I'm sure Muse can merge the other 2 with this one
http://boards.adultswim.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/82880
8



All that is needed, is for the title of this thread to be changed.

 

A catch all hate thread is NOT what people want to talk about, and it is not what I am trying to post in.

 

 

A single thread that is SPECIFICALLY about kenpachi is what is NEEDED.

I watch adult swim because of Bleach. Everyone in my school watches Bleach.
Order of the Owl
MegaNaraku
Posts: 27,882
Registered: ‎11-26-2009
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64122225

It's just a title. it doesn't matter. helpme doesn't need to change it at all.
:heart: Bleach :heart: :heart: Me IRL :heart: :heart: Sword Art Online :heart:

I'm an Owl! PSN: DemonLord99

~Proud business man of the Galactic Bird Flower Gang~

~And a proud member of Team 10,000~

SwimLucky
forethought
Posts: 777
Registered: ‎07-27-2008
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to MegaNaraku - Message ID#: 64122909


MegaNaraku wrote:
It's just a title. it doesn't matter. helpme doesn't need to change it at all.


How can you say that? Kenpachi isnt even in the title, and the title is about "HATE"...

 

this isnt about hate, this is about viz media allowing one of the main characters of bleach to be completely altered for the worse.

 

 

It is sooo much easier to silence everyone that cares about this issue when it it burried in 4 page long post that has no mention of kenpachi, and talks about "HATE"

I watch adult swim because of Bleach. Everyone in my school watches Bleach.
Order of the Owl
MegaNaraku
Posts: 27,882
Registered: ‎11-26-2009
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64124329

Indeed, it is hate. but it is for the voice actors. If you hate certain voice actors, this is the place to discuss it. So it can still be about hate or dislike.
:heart: Bleach :heart: :heart: Me IRL :heart: :heart: Sword Art Online :heart:

I'm an Owl! PSN: DemonLord99

~Proud business man of the Galactic Bird Flower Gang~

~And a proud member of Team 10,000~

SwimLucky
forethought
Posts: 777
Registered: ‎07-27-2008
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to MegaNaraku - Message ID#: 64124533


MegaNaraku wrote:
Indeed, it is hate. but it is for the voice actors. If you hate certain voice actors, this is the place to discuss it. So it can still be about hate or dislike.


Why would anyone hate the voice actors?

Dislike that the voice of kenpachi was destroyed, is a reasonable feeling. The voice actor did nothing wrong, but patrick seltz cannot do kenpachi voice justice.

 

 

 

Viz media was wrong to not try to find a suitable replacement. Adult swim was wrong to allow them to get away with it. Taking one voice actor and (forcing) having him do doubletime, is not acceptable.

 

Studiopolis, Inc.

Email: ####

Website: www.StudiopolisInc.com

Mailing Address:
Studiopolis, Inc.
11700 Ventura Blvd.
Studio City, CA 91604

 

If studiopolis is responsible, then viz media and adult swim are best position to convince them to fix their mistake.

 


 

I watch adult swim because of Bleach. Everyone in my school watches Bleach.
SwimCount
Lord-Tony
Posts: 345
Registered: ‎03-11-2009
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to helpme - Message ID#: 64037575

Have you guys heard Kenpachi's new laugh? It's horrible.

 

 

"NAH-hahahahahaha!"

SwimSuperfan
silver74
Posts: 3,995
Registered: ‎06-15-2010

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64124329

The thread isnt just about kenny v/a its for any v/a you dont like:smileyindifferent:

SwimHipster
robertje
Posts: 1,791
Registered: ‎11-23-2009

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64124821

are you kidding me its really not that much different. besides some crappy one liners its not terrible it deff could be in the ball park of senbonzakura but it isnt. ALL THESE KENPACHI FAN BOYS NEED TO STEP OFF!!!

"Si vis paccem parra bellum" -If you want peace prepare for war!
"Watching in the darkness, Forever in darkness, a guardian devil"
"You can't end a good party without someone on the floor" -Yusuke Urameshi
Otaku Info Broker
helpme
Posts: 40,179
Registered: ‎07-27-2004
0

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64122061


forethought wrote:

Vis media seems to be aware of the upset this is causing.. and are attempting to redirect the blame to ..

 

Studiopolis, Inc. is an American production company that specializes in voiceover recording and dubbing for animation, Japanese anime, and video games.

They were formerly known as Studio E Productions up until 2005. The studio produced the English version of the German animated film, Felidae which was only released on the film's DVD, only around Germany, Switzerland & Austria.

 

{removed}
Studiopolis, Inc.

Email: {removed}

Website: www.StudiopolisInc.com

Mailing Address:
{removed}

 

This is the studio responisble for chosing to pick Patrick Seitz ---- who they already have as a voice actor for ishin kurosaki--- as the "best" to replace kenpachi. I have to wonder if they even cared enough to find someone that could ACTUALLY do the kenpachi voice, tone, and mannerisms.

 

A larger website that is devoted to convincing them to change their poor poor choice is ideal.

 

But instead of posting in this dead end, thread that was designed to herd all of us into a catch all thread to be forgotten, we should be putting as much pressure on adult swim, and viz media to get this insult to fans fixed.


ok first off I'm getting pretty tired of the Kenpachi fans being a nonsense troll

its a voice actor if he's doesn't want to voice him let him have his choice

and get over it

 

second advertising Email is not allowed here and that is a bannable offense

 

like I said before if you really have a Problem take it up with the Mods choose from the list 

or go to the Hey Mod Thread  and ask why they locked it

 

don't be coming in here just to stir #### up it won't end well

I for one won't tolerate all these attempts to get a argument going all because the other 2 threads were locked

this is more of a Discussion thread toward the voice actors that are BAD if you can find another word for HATE tell me now and I'll correct it

MyAnimeList
Anime Manga More website
Either way Don't have fun or I will hunt it down and kill it ~SwimModPerseus
Take a chill pill. Log off. You're being a jackass, and it's annoying ~SwimOdin
Come back from a weekend and you guys are trying to castrate each other Jeeze ~SwimMod_Bast
Knight SwimDeath main account 














Otaku Info Broker
helpme
Posts: 40,179
Registered: ‎07-27-2004

Re: Voice Actor Change Thread *The Hate Edition*

Reply to forethought - Message ID#: 64124329


forethought wrote:

MegaNaraku wrote:
It's just a title. it doesn't matter. helpme doesn't need to change it at all.


How can you say that? Kenpachi isnt even in the title, and the title is about "HATE"... towards all voice actor changes

 

this isnt about hate, this is about viz media allowing one of the main characters of bleach to be completely altered for the worse.

 

 

It is sooo much easier to silence everyone that cares about this issue when it it burried in 4 page long post that has no mention of kenpachi, and talks about "HATE"


in green

MyAnimeList
Anime Manga More website
Either way Don't have fun or I will hunt it down and kill it ~SwimModPerseus
Take a chill pill. Log off. You're being a jackass, and it's annoying ~SwimOdin
Come back from a weekend and you guys are trying to castrate each other Jeeze ~SwimMod_Bast
Knight SwimDeath main account